We write our honest review on each company or product, however, we receive a sales commission or other compensation on the products we review. That helps us to support this website. Prices can vary due to changes in promotions or policies. See our full disclosures here.

Home Chef

Meal Kits
$30+$10 Coupon
  • Starting at $7.99 Per Serving
  • 'Customize It' Feature for Protein Flexibility
  • 18 Meal Choices
  • Shipping - Free for orders over $45

Hello Fresh

Meal Kits
$20X4 Coupon
  • $8.74-$9.99 per serving
  • Great Vegetarian meals selection
  • Shipping - $5.99 per box
Play Video

It’s time for another epic battle of the meal kits! This meal kit review will compare two of the greats in the industry: Home Chef and Hello Fresh, which have both been around for some time, with established reputations and track records.

But first, let me introduce you to Home Chef, a company that likes to give delicious new twists to classic family meals kits, and Hello Fresh, a German company operating in the US for a number of years.

Want to know who the winner is in this meal kit comparison battle? Read on and all will be revealed!

How many plans do they offer?

When it comes to flexibility, we like Home Chef. The company provides one plan yet with lots of flexibility, catering to 2, 4 or 6 people. It also offers a range of vegetarian and no-cooking-necessary lunch dishes that take just 5 minutes to prepare. There is however a weekly minimum requirement of 2 dishes, yet there is no maximum limit so you can order as many meals as you like.

In contrast, Hello Fresh provides 3 plans: The Classic Plan has 15 dishes for 2 or 4 people each week; the Family Plan is based on 6 dishes for 4 people each week; and the Veggie Plan, which has meals for 2 or 4 people each week and a selection of 3 recipes to choose from.

What variety of dishes do they provide?

Home Chef definitely wins in the variety category, with 18 different meals on offer each week. You can select your meals from among any of these 18, no matter which plan you have chosen, or how many people your delivery caters to. The list includes 3 to 4 vegetarian meal kit options and 3 no-cooking-required lunch meals that take just 5 minutes to prepare. Moreover, With their new “Customize It” feature, you can swap proteins, upgrade to a higher quality cut of meat or even double the amount of protein in select meals with the “Customize It” logo.

On the other hand, Hello Fresh provides just 8 meals for the Classic Plan, 5 meals for the Family Plan, and 3 meals in the Vegetarian meal kit Plan. There is the flexibility to change your plan on a weekly basis if you want.

Both contenders, however, are strong in the diversity of the meal styles they provide. The range of cuisines includes varied base ingredients, such as meat, poultry, fish, and vegetables, and a nice range of styles too, such as Italian, Asian, Classic or Mexican.

Japanese teriyaki shrimp bowl by Home chef
Japanese teriyaki shrimp bowl by Home chef

How tasty are they?

Both Home Chef and Hello Fresh meals were really delicious and enjoyable. The two companies share a focus on more classic, well known recipes that are not overly sophisticated and are easy to prepare, and they both encourage adding extra veggies, which is a nice, healthy bonus.

These two companies are great for meal kit ‘newbies’, or those who prefer a simpler cooking experience.

Overall though, we think that Home Chef is a little bit more original, adding a special twist to its recipes that gives some extra interest.

New York Steak by Hello Fresh
New York Steak by Hello Fresh

How is the quality of the ingredients?

I’m pleased to report that Home Chef and Hello Fresh both use products and ingredients in their meal kit that are high in quality.  

Home Chef sources its ingredients from a number of excellent food suppliers, including fresh vegetables and herbs from ‘World Wide Farms’, Paysan Breton Butter, and ‘Sea to Table’ for fresh quality seafood that is sourced sustainably.

On the other hand, the meats used in Hello Fresh meal kits are sourced mainly from domestic suppliers, and are hormone free. The company claims that all poultry products are free of hormones and antibiotics. They use hormone-free certified pork, and seafood that is sourced naturally and sustainably. Although the vegetables used by Hello Fresh are sometimes not organic, they are reliable of excellent, high quality.

The company also claims that it wants to help its customers lead a healthier lifestyle by providing more vegetables and fruits in its meal kits, regardless of whether or not they are organically sourced.

What about the packaging?

Home Chef and Hello Fresh deliveries come in good quality carton boxes that are well labeled featuring the logo of the company. Both companies are also great with organizing the contents inside the boxes, arranging them properly in separate labeled bags. When it’s time to unpack your delivery, this really cuts down on the hassle for you.

Refrigerated ingredients, such as meat, fish and other proteins, like tofu, are packed in ice at the base of the box, so your delivery stays cool and fresh. This means the box can wait on your doorstep for a few hours if need be, without you having to worry.

Home Chef Products
Home Chef Products
hello fresh products
Hello fresh products

How about the app and website?

In the case of both Home Chef and Hello Fresh, the app and website are very handy, organized and user-friendly. Everything you need to do to manage and monitor your account can be done online, such as registering for an account, choosing meals and dietary preferences, editing payment details, and more. The sites also show your past deliveries, and future orders, with information such as the recipe, which ingredients it uses, nutritional data and more.

What are the terms & conditions of the plans?

Both Home Chef and Hello Fresh are subscription-based services, and they both have the flexibility to freeze your subscription for a week here or there if you need. They are also both flexible when it comes to choosing your best delivery day (but take note, this does depend somewhat on your location and address).

Canceling your account is also easy with Home Chef and Hello Fresh, as you can do it online. Both companies also offer customer support, and you can contact them any time for a fast, helpful response.

What add-ons do they offer?

Home Chef provides 4 fantastic add-ons that we love:

  • Smoothie with a different flavor each week for $4.95
  • Basket of seasonal fruit for $4.95
  • No-cooking lunch meals that take just 5 minutes to prepare, at $7.99 each
  • Range of retail kitchenware items, like cookware, knives, utensils and more

In contrast, Hello Fresh has 2 different add ons:

  • A range of handy kitchenware, such as cookware, prep tools, storage items, and knives
  • Wine subscription for 6 bottles of wine a month. This costs $89 per month, and there is a range of wine plans to choose from, including red, white or mixed wine plan.

So, what’s the final verdict?

Home Chef and Hello Fresh are great options, and they both make it onto our top 3 list of favorite meal kit delivery services for people who love classic and traditional meals.
Although it was a tightly placed battle, we had to make a choice, and our favorite of these two strong contenders is Home Chef. we loved their simple and delicious recipes, always with some nice twist, and their plans and weekly menu offer more flexibility than Hello Fresh.

Home Chef is our winner!

  • Tasty meals that are classic and home-style, yet with a slight twist
  • Only takes 30 minutes to cook
  • Good value for money
  • Quality of ingredients is a cut above
  • Related Articles:

    Leave a Reply

    Close Menu