We write our honest review on each product, however, we might receive a sales commission to support this website. Prices can vary due to changes in policies. See our full disclosures here.

One of the main assumptions we hear a lot about meal kit service is how expensive it is, vs. doing the grocery shopping yourself.

Obviously, some companies work out to be more expensive, but some options would be hard to beat when it comes to the price.

Today we will be looking at two meal kit services focussed on the bottom line and provide the cheapest meal kit on the market – Dinnerly and EveryPlate – $5 meal kit battle! 

Continue reading to see our full comparison – Every Plate Vs. Dinnerly

Plans available:

Dinnerly and EveryPlate offer identical meal plan options – The first is a two-person plan with three meals every week. The second plan provides three meals a week for four people

Dinnerly Vs Every Plate Menu variety:

Dinnerly is definitely the winner here, with a menu made up of over 20 different dinner options every week. Plus protein packs and dessert add-ons option.

Dinnerly offers recipes that seemed to be focused on easy and fast cooking. The meals can generally be prepared in 30 minutes or less. The reach menu includes classic meat and seafood meals, vegetarian meals, low carb meals, low-calorie options, gluten-free friendly meals, and kid-friendly meals.

Every Plate has a menu made up of 14 different meals every week. The EveryPlate meals tend to be quite classic, with easy cooking recipes. As an EveryPlate customer, you do have the option to upgrade some meals for $2.99 to include premium items like grass-fed steak or shrimps.

In both menus, you will be able to find meal styles from all around the world:

  • Asian-style meals like Cashew chicken stir-fry with rice noodles from Dinnerly or Vietnamese chicken and rice bowl from Every Plate
  • Tex-Mex style meals like Mexican beef tostadas with guac & cheddar from Dinnerly or Raja’s quesadillas with salsa Fresca from Everyplate 
  • Italian pasta classics like Pizza tortelloni with tomatoes & Cheeses from Dinnerly or Tuscan chicken over creamy tomato linguine from EveryPlate
  • American style meals like carmelized onion burger from EveryPlate or  Philly cheesesteak burger with oven fries from Dinnerly
EveryPlate Unbox
EveryPlate Unboxing
Dinnerly Burgers
Dinnerly Burgers

Quality of ingredients and the taste of Dinnerly and EveryPlate Meal Boxes

At the Meal Kit Comparison, we believe in an extensive review process. Our team tries a varied selection of meals from each company menu. This means our reviews come from the first-hand experience.

After trying both Dinnerly and EveryPlate for several weeks, we can report we were delighted with the meals! Just because these companies offer cheap meal kits does not mean they skimp on high-quality or ingredients. 

All our Dinnerly meals tasted fabulous. We found the quality of the ingredients excellent, and the results were delicious every time. All the meals were easy to cook and looked very appealing. We were also pleasantly surprised by the portion sizes. 

We loved a few meals from the Dinnerly menu: the Brown Butter Tortelloni with Lemon & Baby Spinach and the Pulled pork Mac & Cheese with BBQ sauce.

We had a more or less similar experience with EveryPlate ingredients. We must admit that our expectations were a little lower than they usually are due to the lower prices, but we were pleased with most items we got.

The Everyplate meals were easy to cook when following the easy-to-follow recipe card. The ingredients that were included were all of good quality as well. 

We enjoyed a few meals from the Every Plate menu: the spiced chicken with roasted tomatoes and mashed potatoes and the panko ranched pork chops.

The Delivery of Dinnerly and EveryPlate:

Both EveryPlate and Dinnerly boxes were medium-sized and labeled food delivery boxes. With our Dinnerly delivery, the proteins were placed at the bottom with ice-packs, so the items were still cold when we received the package.

The dinnerly service offers online recipe cards only – so no recipe cards in the box. Also, the ingredients weren’t separated or labeled per meal. Those are part of how Dinnerly keeps their prices low – completely worth the much lower price you pay in comparison to most meal kit services. 

The EveryPlate delivery included a smaller internal box for all dry ingredients and vegetables, and the proteins were packed on the bottom with ice-packs as well.

Included in the delivery are some recipe cards which contain ingredient information and instructions on how to cook your meals. EveryPlate also does not sort their ingredients to keep the packaging to a minimum and their prices low.

Both companies offer some flexibility in choosing your delivery dates based on your home location. Note that the deadline to change your delivery day is five days before your next delivery.

Managing Your Online Account:

Managing your account with both Dinnerly and EveryPlate is very easy to do via their user-friendly websites. For both companies, it is merely a matter of registering to establish your account. Then you can select your preferred plan, choose your meals, and order!

Once you have received your first order, you can view past orders, order meals in advance, change plans, swap meals, etc. You can also contact their online support departments if you ever require any assistance. 

It is important to note that both companies offer good customer service to contact any problem or questions you have regarding the service or your account. Their customer support can be reached via phone, email, or chat.

So, Who’s Our Winner In the Dinnerly Vs Every Plate Battle?

We enjoyed the experience with both companies. We think they both offer an affordable meal kit service with incredible value for money. They genuinely are the cheapest meal kit companies in America. And most importantly, at the end of the day – both companies offer delicious and very satisfying dinners!

Our favorite service between the two is Dinnerly!

First, the Dinnelry variety of meals is much larger. With over 20 meals on the menu, everyone can find something they would love to eat. 

Moreover, we loved that their menu features many meal options for diets like vegetarians, low carb, low-calorie, dairy-free, and more. It seems that dinnerly is more focused on healthy lifestyle meals.

Lastly, all the dishes we tried from their menu (and we tried quite a few!) were delicious, satisfying, and contained high-quality ingredients, despite the incredibly low price.


Dinnerly is our winner!

  • Most affordable - starting at $4.69 per serving!
  • 16 delicious recipes per week.
  • Super fast to cook, with less fuss.
  • Kid-friendly, vegetarian, low-calorie, low-carb meals.
  • Desserts and protein packs are available.
  • Related Articles: